Frontierby eninvs

Language: EN / RU

← All research
Dark theme

CSN: steel and iron ore fell while coking coal rose – EBITDA collapsed 81.9%, and the share price does not reflect it yet

Contents
CSN

On 16 November CSN released its third-quarter 2026 results. The average hot-rolled coil price in China was 3313 yuan per tonne for the quarter, 3.0% below a year earlier; iron ore fell 5.2% to 97.3 dollars, while coking coal, which the company buys, rose 27.7% to 242.8 dollars. Revenue fell 12.0% to 1928.5 million dollars, EBITDA 81.9% to 93.1 million, and net profit was a loss of 229.4 million. At the year-ago prices, volumes and costs, our calculation puts EBITDA at 347.4 million dollars – the company earned 254.2 million less. Our conclusion: the share is rather unattractive – at today's prices the portal spot model puts annual EBITDA at 116.8 million dollars and EV/EBITDA on that base at 72.8. Our view: the share is rather unattractive at the current price.

Our view: is there upside

Our view in numbers

MetricOur read
VerdictRather unattractive
Upside on the portal modelno portal model for this share
Net debt / EBITDA8.01 – high leverage
Strongest case forIron ore reserves last 40.4 years, and if ore returns to 97.3 dollars per tonne and coal to 242.8 dollars, EBITDA would return to levels at which the 7668.0 million dollars of net debt is serviceable.
Strongest case againstAt today's prices EV/EBITDA on the portal spot model is 72.8 and net debt is 65.7 times EBITDA, with negative quarterly operating cash flow of 138.4 million dollars.
What would change the viewThe verdict would move a step up if iron ore held above 97.3 dollars per tonne and coking coal below 242.8 dollars: that would return EBITDA to levels at which EV/EBITDA falls below 20.

Key takeaways

— Steel and iron ore prices fell while coking coal rose – the price backdrop alone cost 75.4 million dollars of revenue and added 91.1 million of costs

— At the year-ago prices, our calculation puts EBITDA at 347.4 million dollars against 93.1 million reported – the 254.2 million gap is not only price

— Revenue fell 12.0% year on year after 16.1% growth a quarter earlier – a sharp deceleration, and the portal spot model expected 2090.3 million dollars against 1928.5 million actual

— The EBITDA margin compressed from 23.5% to 4.8%, and with coking coal at 242.8 dollars costs bite harder than revenue shows

— Leverage is 8.01 times trailing-twelve-month EBITDA – a level that becomes 65.7 times EBITDA at today's prices

— At today's prices the portal spot model puts annual EBITDA at 116.8 million dollars against 1050.3 million over the last twelve months, and valuation should start from the former

— Reserves last 40.4 years at the current production rate – the one thing that does not depend on price

Key figures, USD bn

MetricQ3 2025Q3 2026Change
Revenue2.191.93-12.0%
EBITDA0.510.09-81.9%
Operating profit0.32-0.11-132.8%
Net profit0.01-0.23-1715.1%
Operating cash flow0.07-0.14-289.8%
Capex0.270.25-4.6%
EBITDA margin23.5%4.8%-18.7 pp
Net margin0.6%-11.9%-12.5 pp

Steel and iron ore prices fell while coking coal rose – the price backdrop alone cost 75.4 million dollars of revenue and added 91.1 million of costs

The average hot-rolled coil price in China was 3313 yuan per tonne in the third quarter of 2026, 3.0% below a year earlier and 2.2% below the previous quarter. Iron ore averaged 97.3 dollars per tonne against 102.6 dollars a year earlier, down 5.2%. Spot on 16 November puts coil at 3180 yuan, another 4.0% below the quarterly average, and ore at 89.9 dollars, 7.6% lower.

Coking coal, which the company buys, moved the other way: 242.8 dollars per tonne against 190.1 dollars a year earlier, up 27.7%. Against the previous quarter the rise is smaller at 2.0%. Spot coal is 252 dollars, another 3.8% above the quarterly average.

At the year-ago volumes and non-commodity costs, with only these prices moving, our calculation puts revenue at 2115.9 million dollars – a price effect of minus 75.4 million, or minus 3.4% – while dearer coal would have added 91.1 million to costs. The price backdrop explains only part of the collapse, but it sets the direction.

Commodity prices: period average and now

BenchmarkYear agoQ3 2026YoYSpot 2026-11-16
Hot rolled coil, USDCNY3 4153 313-3,0%3 180
Iron Ore, USD102,697,3-5,2%89,9
Coking coal (input cost), USD190,1242,8+27,7%252,0
EBITDA and the commodity price by quarter
EBITDA and the commodity price by quarter

At the year-ago prices, our calculation puts EBITDA at 347.4 million dollars against 93.1 million reported – the 254.2 million gap is not only price

At the third-quarter 2025 volumes and costs and the reported-period prices, revenue should have been 2115.9 million dollars and EBITDA 347.4 million. Actual revenue was 1928.5 million, 187.4 million less, and EBITDA 93.1 million, 254.2 million less – 73.2% below the calculated figure.

The 8.9% revenue gap against the calculation shows price is not the whole story: at unchanged volumes the price effect was minus 3.4%. The rest comes from volumes and realised price against the benchmark, but the facts give no production or shipment figures, so we state the gap and leave it there.

The portal spot model, re-priced from the average of the previous four quarters, expected EBITDA of 232.3 million dollars and revenue of 2090.3 million. The actual figures are 59.9% below the model on EBITDA and 7.7% below on revenue. In the four preceding periods the deviation was +40.6%, -22.9%, -9.6% and +4.8% – this quarter's miss is well outside the usual range.

What the prices implied and what the company earned

Base (Q3 2025)Implied at period pricesReportedReported vs implied
Revenue, USD mn2 1912 1161 928-8,9%
EBITDA, USD mn513,9347,493,1-73,2%
EBITDA, portal spot model, USD mn—232,393,1-59,9%

Revenue and EBITDA by quarter

PeriodMeasurebn USD
Q4 2024Revenue1.3135
Q1 2025Revenue1.940859
Q2 2025Revenue1.9179410000000001
Q3 2025Revenue2.191354
Q4 2025Revenue2.082313
Q1 2026Revenue2.1133580000000003
Q2 2026Revenue2.226456
Q3 2026Revenue1.928529
Q4 2024EBITDA0.36996100000000004
Q1 2025EBITDA0.33573400000000003
Q2 2025EBITDA0.482361
Q3 2025EBITDA0.5139239999999999
Q4 2025EBITDA0.296744
Q1 2026EBITDA0.288888
Q2 2026EBITDA0.371555
Q3 2026EBITDA0.09312700000000002

EBITDA margin

PeriodMeasure%
Q4 2024EBITDA margin28.2
Q1 2025EBITDA margin17.3
Q2 2025EBITDA margin25.1
Q3 2025EBITDA margin23.5
Q4 2025EBITDA margin14.3
Q1 2026EBITDA margin13.7
Q2 2026EBITDA margin16.7
Q3 2026EBITDA margin4.8

Revenue fell 12.0% year on year after 16.1% growth a quarter earlier – a sharp deceleration, and the portal spot model expected 2090.3 million dollars against 1928.5 million actual

Third-quarter 2026 revenue was 1928.5 million dollars, 12.0% below a year earlier. In the second quarter it grew 16.1%, so the trend decelerated sharply. For a company where the portal model puts 55% of revenue in steel and 35% in iron ore, the downward turn in both prices explains most of that deceleration.

The portal spot model expected 2090.3 million dollars – the actual figure is 7.7% below. Even after adjusting for prices, the company sold less than a model built on its own previous four quarters assumed.

Quarterly revenue in 2026: 2113.4 million in the first quarter, 2226.5 million in the second and 1928.5 million in the third. The 13.4% drop against the previous quarter coincides with cheaper steel and cheaper ore.

The EBITDA margin compressed from 23.5% to 4.8%, and with coking coal at 242.8 dollars costs bite harder than revenue shows

Third-quarter EBITDA was 93.1 million dollars, 81.9% below a year earlier. The margin fell from 23.5% to 4.8%. The operating result turned negative at minus 105.1 million dollars, and depreciation of 198.2 million is the only reason EBITDA stayed positive.

Coking coal rose 27.7% year on year, which our price-effect calculation puts at 91.1 million dollars of extra costs. Against revenue of 1928.5 million that is worth almost five percentage points of margin the company does not have.

The net loss was 229.4 million dollars against a 14.2 million profit a year earlier. The net margin is minus 11.9% against plus 0.6%. Part of the loss sits below the operating line, but the source does not break out the items, so we state the figure and stop there.

Leverage is 8.01 times trailing-twelve-month EBITDA – a level that becomes 65.7 times EBITDA at today's prices

Net debt at 30 September 2026 was 7668.0 million dollars. Against trailing-twelve-month EBITDA of 957.1 million that is 8.01 times. Operating cash flow for the quarter was negative at minus 138.4 million dollars, and capital expenditure was 254.5 million – the quarter's investment was not covered by operating cash flow.

At today's prices the portal spot model puts annual EBITDA at 116.8 million dollars. On that base net debt is 65.7 times EBITDA and EV/EBITDA is 72.8. This is not a valuation of the company but an illustration of how far current earnings are from the debt.

Over the last twelve months EBITDA was 1050.3 million dollars, and EV/EBITDA on that base is 8.09. But those twelve months included quarters with higher steel and iron ore prices, and they cannot be relied on at today's spot.

At today's prices the portal spot model puts annual EBITDA at 116.8 million dollars against 1050.3 million over the last twelve months, and valuation should start from the former

The portal spot model re-prices the trailing-twelve-month base at today's prices. That gives EBITDA of 116.8 million dollars, 88.9% below the 1050.3 million over the last twelve months. For a commodity producer this is the earnings base valuation should start from: the past twelve months were earned at different prices.

EV/EBITDA on that base is 72.8 and net debt to EBITDA is 65.7. With a market capitalisation of 833.8 million dollars and net debt of 7668.0 million, the enterprise is worth about 8502 million, and at EBITDA of 116.8 million a multiple of 72.8 is unavoidable.

Iron ore reserves last 40.4 years at the current production rate. That is the one metric independent of price and it confirms the asset is long-lived – but it does not service debt this quarter.

Share price, three years

close, last point 2026-11-13

PeriodMeasureUSD per share
2025-11-14Closing price1.6100000143051147
2025-11-17Closing price1.5499999523162842
2025-11-18Closing price1.5299999713897705
2025-11-19Closing price1.5199999809265137
2025-11-20Closing price1.4800000190734863
2025-11-21Closing price1.5
2025-11-24Closing price1.4900000095367432
2025-11-25Closing price1.5499999523162842
2025-11-26Closing price1.6100000143051147
2025-11-28Closing price1.5800000429153442
2025-12-01Closing price1.590000033378601
2025-12-02Closing price1.6200000047683716
2025-12-03Closing price1.7100000381469727
2025-12-04Closing price1.7799999713897705
2025-12-05Closing price1.6399999856948853
2025-12-08Closing price1.6100000143051147
2025-12-09Closing price1.6699999570846558
2025-12-10Closing price1.7599999904632568
2025-12-11Closing price1.809999942779541
2025-12-12Closing price1.809999942779541
2025-12-15Closing price1.7400000095367432
2025-12-16Closing price1.7400000095367432
2025-12-17Closing price1.7300000190734863
2025-12-18Closing price1.7699999809265137
2025-12-19Closing price1.6299999952316284
2025-12-22Closing price1.6399999856948853
2025-12-23Closing price1.6399999856948853
2025-12-24Closing price1.6200000047683716
2025-12-26Closing price1.6200000047683716
2025-12-29Closing price1.5800000429153442
2025-12-30Closing price1.6299999952316284
2025-12-31Closing price1.600000023841858
2026-01-02Closing price1.6100000143051147
2026-01-05Closing price1.6699999570846558
2026-01-06Closing price1.75
2026-01-07Closing price1.8799999952316284
2026-01-08Closing price1.8700000047683716
2026-01-09Closing price1.8600000143051147
2026-01-12Closing price1.8700000047683716
2026-01-13Closing price1.8700000047683716
2026-01-14Closing price1.9500000476837158
2026-01-15Closing price1.899999976158142
2026-01-16Closing price1.7899999618530273
2026-01-20Closing price1.7000000476837158
2026-01-21Closing price1.7799999713897705
2026-01-22Closing price1.8200000524520874
2026-01-23Closing price1.9500000476837158
2026-01-26Closing price1.899999976158142
2026-01-27Closing price2.059999942779541
2026-01-28Closing price2.119999885559082
2026-01-29Closing price2.059999942779541
2026-01-30Closing price1.909999966621399
2026-02-02Closing price1.899999976158142
2026-02-03Closing price2.009999990463257
2026-02-04Closing price1.9600000381469727
2026-02-05Closing price1.8899999856948853
2026-02-06Closing price1.8300000429153442
2026-02-09Closing price1.899999976158142
2026-02-10Closing price1.8300000429153442
2026-02-11Closing price1.8799999952316284
2026-02-12Closing price1.7000000476837158
2026-02-13Closing price1.690000057220459
2026-02-17Closing price1.6799999475479126
2026-02-18Closing price1.659999966621399
2026-02-19Closing price1.659999966621399
2026-02-20Closing price1.7000000476837158
2026-02-23Closing price1.6699999570846558
2026-02-24Closing price1.6699999570846558
2026-02-25Closing price1.7000000476837158
2026-02-26Closing price1.7000000476837158
2026-02-27Closing price1.6799999475479126
2026-03-02Closing price1.6399999856948853
2026-03-03Closing price1.5
2026-03-04Closing price1.5499999523162842
2026-03-05Closing price1.4700000286102295
2026-03-06Closing price1.3899999856948853
2026-03-09Closing price1.4199999570846558
2026-03-10Closing price1.409999966621399
2026-03-11Closing price1.3799999952316284
2026-03-12Closing price1.2000000476837158
2026-03-13Closing price1.1100000143051147
2026-03-16Closing price1.1699999570846558
2026-03-17Closing price1.2000000476837158
2026-03-18Closing price1.1699999570846558
2026-03-19Closing price1.190000057220459
2026-03-20Closing price1.1399999856948853
2026-03-23Closing price1.25
2026-03-24Closing price1.2400000095367432
2026-03-25Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-03-26Closing price1.2300000190734863
2026-03-27Closing price1.2100000381469727
2026-03-30Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-03-31Closing price1.2400000095367432
2026-04-01Closing price1.2699999809265137
2026-04-02Closing price1.2599999904632568
2026-04-06Closing price1.2599999904632568
2026-04-07Closing price1.2400000095367432
2026-04-08Closing price1.3300000429153442
2026-04-09Closing price1.350000023841858
2026-04-10Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-04-13Closing price1.3200000524520874
2026-04-14Closing price1.350000023841858
2026-04-15Closing price1.3700000047683716
2026-04-16Closing price1.340000033378601
2026-04-17Closing price1.3600000143051147
2026-04-20Closing price1.3799999952316284
2026-04-21Closing price1.2999999523162842
2026-04-22Closing price1.340000033378601
2026-04-23Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-04-24Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-04-27Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-04-28Closing price1.2999999523162842
2026-04-29Closing price1.2699999809265137
2026-04-30Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-05-01Closing price1.2899999618530273
2026-05-04Closing price1.2599999904632568
2026-05-05Closing price1.2999999523162842
2026-05-06Closing price1.399999976158142
2026-05-07Closing price1.340000033378601
2026-05-08Closing price1.3799999952316284
2026-05-11Closing price1.3700000047683716
2026-05-12Closing price1.3700000047683716
2026-05-13Closing price1.2799999713897705
2026-05-14Closing price1.350000023841858
2026-05-15Closing price1.2599999904632568
2026-05-18Closing price1.25
2026-05-19Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-05-20Closing price1.25
2026-05-21Closing price1.2799999713897705
2026-05-22Closing price1.350000023841858
2026-05-26Closing price1.340000033378601
2026-05-27Closing price1.3200000524520874
2026-05-28Closing price1.3600000143051147
2026-05-29Closing price1.350000023841858
2026-06-01Closing price1.309999942779541
2026-06-02Closing price1.4199999570846558
2026-06-03Closing price1.309999942779541
2026-06-04Closing price1.2999999523162842
2026-06-05Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-06-08Closing price1.149999976158142
2026-06-09Closing price1.1699999570846558
2026-06-10Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-06-11Closing price1.2100000381469727
2026-06-12Closing price1.2200000286102295
2026-06-15Closing price1.2200000286102295
2026-06-16Closing price1.2100000381469727
2026-06-17Closing price1.1200000047683716
2026-06-18Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-06-22Closing price1.0499999523162842
2026-06-23Closing price1.0399999618530273
2026-06-24Closing price0.9800000190734863
2026-06-25Closing price0.9599999785423279
2026-06-26Closing price0.9399999976158142
2026-06-29Closing price0.9100000262260437
2026-06-30Closing price0.9200000166893005
2026-07-01Closing price0.8999999761581421
2026-07-02Closing price0.9100000262260437
2026-07-06Closing price0.9599999785423279
2026-07-07Closing price0.9300000071525574
2026-07-08Closing price0.9200000166893005
2026-07-09Closing price0.949999988079071
2026-07-10Closing price1.0099999904632568
2026-07-13Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-07-14Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-07-15Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-07-16Closing price1.0
2026-07-17Closing price0.9900000095367432
2026-07-20Closing price1.0099999904632568
2026-07-21Closing price1.0
2026-07-22Closing price1.090000033378601
2026-07-23Closing price1.059999942779541
2026-07-24Closing price1.0800000429153442
2026-07-27Closing price1.1200000047683716
2026-07-28Closing price1.100000023841858
2026-07-29Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-07-30Closing price1.0099999904632568
2026-07-31Closing price0.9900000095367432
2026-08-03Closing price0.9300000071525574
2026-08-04Closing price0.9399999976158142
2026-08-05Closing price0.9800000190734863
2026-08-06Closing price0.9399999976158142
2026-08-07Closing price0.9300000071525574
2026-08-10Closing price0.8999999761581421
2026-08-11Closing price0.8700000047683716
2026-08-12Closing price0.8700000047683716
2026-08-13Closing price0.8999999761581421
2026-08-14Closing price0.8899999856948853
2026-08-17Closing price0.8999999761581421
2026-08-18Closing price0.8999999761581421
2026-08-19Closing price0.8799999952316284
2026-08-20Closing price0.8899999856948853
2026-08-21Closing price0.9800000190734863
2026-08-24Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-08-25Closing price1.0199999809265137
2026-08-26Closing price1.0299999713897705
2026-08-27Closing price1.059999942779541
2026-08-28Closing price1.0199999809265137
2026-08-31Closing price1.0399999618530273
2026-09-01Closing price1.1299999952316284
2026-09-02Closing price1.1699999570846558
2026-09-03Closing price1.2599999904632568
2026-09-04Closing price1.2200000286102295
2026-09-08Closing price1.2400000095367432
2026-09-09Closing price1.3300000429153442
2026-09-10Closing price1.3799999952316284
2026-09-11Closing price1.2699999809265137
2026-09-14Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-09-15Closing price1.2000000476837158
2026-09-16Closing price1.2100000381469727
2026-09-17Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-09-18Closing price1.100000023841858
2026-09-21Closing price1.1699999570846558
2026-09-22Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-09-23Closing price1.1399999856948853
2026-09-24Closing price1.100000023841858
2026-09-25Closing price1.100000023841858
2026-09-28Closing price1.1100000143051147
2026-09-29Closing price1.0199999809265137
2026-09-30Closing price1.059999942779541
2026-10-01Closing price1.1200000047683716
2026-10-02Closing price1.159999966621399
2026-10-05Closing price1.2400000095367432
2026-10-06Closing price1.2300000190734863
2026-10-07Closing price1.2300000190734863
2026-10-08Closing price1.2300000190734863
2026-10-09Closing price1.2799999713897705
2026-10-12Closing price1.2699999809265137
2026-10-13Closing price1.2400000095367432
2026-10-14Closing price1.2100000381469727
2026-10-15Closing price1.149999976158142
2026-10-16Closing price1.1100000143051147
2026-10-19Closing price1.1299999952316284
2026-10-20Closing price1.159999966621399
2026-10-21Closing price1.100000023841858
2026-10-22Closing price1.0399999618530273
2026-10-23Closing price1.1799999475479126
2026-10-26Closing price0.9100000262260437
2026-10-27Closing price0.8700000047683716
2026-10-28Closing price0.800000011920929
2026-10-29Closing price0.7799999713897705
2026-10-30Closing price0.7200000286102295
2026-11-02Closing price0.7200000286102295
2026-11-03Closing price0.7099999785423279
2026-11-04Closing price0.7799999713897705
2026-11-05Closing price0.7799999713897705
2026-11-06Closing price0.8500000238418579
2026-11-09Closing price0.8199999928474426
2026-11-10Closing price0.8100000023841858
2026-11-11Closing price0.8299999833106995
2026-11-12Closing price0.7699999809265137
2026-11-13Closing price0.6299999952316284

Reserves last 40.4 years at the current production rate – the one thing that does not depend on price

At the current production rate iron ore reserves last 40.4 years. For a company with 35% of revenue in iron ore, that means the question is not depletion of the base but price and costs.

Spot ore on 16 November was 89.9 dollars per tonne, 7.6% below the reported-quarter average. If that price holds, the next quarter's price effect will be worse than the third. It is the price of ore and steel, not volumes, that will determine whether EBITDA returns to levels at which the debt is serviceable.

Valuation on the latest reported figures

MetricValue
Market cap0.83 bn USD
EV/EBITDA (LTM)8.1
P/B0.29
Net debt / EBITDA (LTM)8.01
ROE-33.3%

Net profit by quarter

PeriodMeasurebn USD
Q4 2024Net profit−0.013758
Q1 2025Net profit−0.130174
Q2 2025Net profit−0.023382999999999998
Q3 2025Net profit0.014202999999999999
Q4 2025Net profit−0.13169999999999998
Q1 2026Net profit−0.11061700000000001
Q2 2026Net profit−0.152234
Q3 2026Net profit−0.229399

Bottom line

The only genuinely strong item in the report is that iron ore reserves last 40.4 years, and that does not depend on price. Everything else worked against the company: steel fell 3.0%, ore 5.2%, coking coal rose 27.7%, and EBITDA dropped 81.9% to 93.1 million dollars at a 4.8% margin. At the year-ago prices our calculation puts EBITDA at 347.4 million – the 254.2 million gap is not explained by price alone, but even without it the picture is heavy. The real question for a holder now is not revenue but debt: 7668.0 million dollars of net debt against the portal spot model's 116.8 million of EBITDA is 65.7 times. Our conclusion: the share is rather unattractive – at today's prices EV/EBITDA on the portal spot model is 72.8, which leaves no cushion. Our view: the share is rather unattractive at the current price.